Phone: (845) 255-0177

125 Dubois Rd. * New Paltz, NY 12561





OUR 501c






We enjoy making horse and pony shopping stress-free. Our horses and ponies are available for inspection and trial, by appointment. We are the area's oldest farm in the area. Buy with confidence! Our staff is friendly, professional and knowledgeable in all aspects of evaluating, appraising, selling, leasing and buying horses and ponies. Make an appointment to view our affordable, quality selection of horses and ponies for sale. Delivery and shipping assistance always available.

 'MANGO' -Ready to Ride! Sweet, 6 yr old, 15h, mare. Pretty jump, easy way of going. Ring or Trails. Loads/ships, stands to be groomed/tacked, good manners, no vices. W-T-C, swaps, jumps the jumps in style. Suitable for child or adult. Would be easy horse to take care of for mom/daughter. Lovely for Dressage!  Quietly jumps around the 2'-2'6".  Trail riding DELUXE. Ideal for size for petite adult. $7,500/neg to good home.

'Cheyenne' - From Trail Riding to Cowboy Dressage, Western/English, HUSBAND SAFE!  BEAUTIFUL BUCKSKIN, 15h, 10yr, sweet mare. NOT SPOOKY or HOT. Happy to ride out alone or with company. Solid, sure footed, clean legs, steady and willing. Good manners, load/ships, bathes, ties/stands, healthy/sound, up to date with farrier/vet. Priced under $4,800/neg to good home.  NEW! click here to see her NEW video

'Lollipop' - SAFE and HONEST DELUXE Riding Pony! Large 14.1h, 10 yr old, dun, pony, gelding. Has been shown Short Stirrup - 2'-2'6" and trail ridden. Sadly outgrown and must be sold.  Reasonably priced $6500/to good home.

Watch LOLLIPOP- Sadly Outgrown Riding/Jumping Video   

Click here to watch LOLLIPOP with BEGINNERS

'RODEO' - NOVICE FRIENDLY! F-L-A-S-H-Y Registered PtHA (Pinto), 14 yr, 15.2h, sweet gelding. M-A-D-E ! Great ground manners, safe and healthy/sound. IN THE RING OR ON THE TRAILS- 'Rodeo' is your new horse! English / Western, Jumps. Comfortable gaits, easy keeper who can live at home with you! No vices. Up to date. $6,500/neg to good home

click here to watch RODEO's video

'14 Karrot'- JUST SOLD!   Click here to watch her video :)


'SONNY' - Great WESTERN RIDING HORSE! RARE PALOMINO and WHITE Pinto colored, Kentucky bred- READY TO WIN A PAY CHECK FOR YOU! Gymkhanas, Rodeos, Ranch, Trails, Cow, Sorting - No alley/chute/pen/arena issues. Handy, quick, sure footed, SANE! This HANDSOME GELDING really NECK REINS! - Asking $4,800.00/neg. to good home.

NEW on the Market- Watch SONNY



Fabulous HOMEBRED, filly! Gentle Giant! W-T-C, Trail rides. Professional training! Home raised!  Kind and simple to ride! Comfortable ride! Excellent prospect to show, hunt and trail ride!  - LEASED for 2014 - Congratulations Cathy :)

 'Blackjax' - Handsome 16h, 10 yr, black/white blanketed Appaloosa, gelding.  Good riding horse with no vices and no issues! CONFIDENCE BUILDER DELUXE! - JUST SOLD -   click here to watch BLACKJAX video 



'Pippin' - SHARP DRESSED MAN! Black/white, 2007 (pending Registration) Pinto, 15.3h, quiet, gelding. Shown in Showmanship, English and Western Pleasure, Trail class. QUIET, SAFE AND SANE! No vices, up-to-date, loads/ships, stands to be tied and ready to go to his new home. Suitable for Novice to advanced rider, child or adult.  Priced under $10k.


'DALLAS'- TRUE PLEASURE horse - CONFIDENCE BUILDER! No trainer required! REAL PRETTY, M-A-D-E Western (or English) Pleasure horse! 12yr old, beautiful bay, 16h, Registered AQHA Quarter Horse, GENTLE mare. Has two owners, shown OPEN and AQHA. Walk/Jog/Trot DELUXE for ANYONE. Perfect for LEARN TO LOPE/CANTER! TIMID RIDERS WELCOME! Sound, loads/ships, stands/ties, no vices. Show or recreation, this is your new horse! WATCH HER VIDEO NOW  - Reasonably priced under $10k/neg. This girl is as close to unflappable as you can ask for! GRANDMA SAFE! -

Click here to see this unflappable pleasure mare!


'Lexy'- SAFE, SMOOTH TRAIL RIDING DELUXE! - Beautiful dark bay, Kentucky Mountain horse, 15h, gentle mare. Rides with or without company! No vices. TRAIL RIDE LIKE A PRO on LEXY! Novices/recreational and returning rider FRIENDLY! Good manners, loads/ships, stands/ties. Solid, sane and sound. Don't wait, too good to last long! $5,000 - DON'T WAIT FOR THE VIDEO, COME BUY HER TODAY!
'PATTY' - BRAND NEW ON THE MARKET! Beautiful, big bodied, 16h, buckskin, 8 year old, SWEET, home raised mare. W-T-C, Jumps, Trail rides, Hunter Paces. Loads/ships, bathes, stands/ties. Excellent manners, happy, healthy/sound. 'Patty' is ready to go cubbing, hill topping or fox hunting.  Reasonably priced.

 Click her to WATCH PATTY's VIDEO :)

too new for photo

 'NOBLE' -Quiet English Riding Gelding - SCHOOLMASTER INCLUDING JUMPING! No prep needed!11yr old, handsome bay, 16h, Quarter Horse, gelding. Quiet, CONFIDENCE BUILDING English riding horse. Jumps, knows leads/swaps.  Clean legs, good feet, passes vet, loads/ships, stands/ties, no vices. Just put your foot in the stirrup and this babysitter will do the rest! Dependable and safe! Reasonably priced under $10k - JUST SOLD!


'HONEY' - Too cute and SAFE, learning pony for your kids! Well mannered, quiet. W-T-C, poles, X-rails. Super Leadline pony!  Healthy, sound, loads/ships.  click to watch her trot video     -  click here to see her JUMP!


'SHEZA COWGIRL' - CAN LIVE AT HOME! Gentle bay, 6 year old, 16h, Quarter Horse, SWEET mare. Super well broke with solid training and good experience. Good ranch and roping horse, sorted/worked cattle, loped reining patterns, turned a few cans (barrel racing), weaved poles, knows her leads, swaps, spins, rollbacks, good 'Whoa'...Neckreins! - Handy horse that can go in any direction you want. She's even been ridden English and trail rides. Previous experience competing in Versatility, Rodeos, Western Riding and Trail class. RIDES alone or in company.  IMPECCABLE MANNERS! Loads/ships, stands/ties, bathes/clips/fly sprays. No vices. Happy and healthy. Asking $6,000/good home. Click here to get an appointment 

Click here to see PRINCESS's VIDEO



Don't wait ... Call (845) 255-0177 and BUY YOUR NEW HORSE TODAY!


PLEASE DONATE TODAY! We encourage visitors to MAKE A DONATION to the Payne Farm Foundation. The Payne Farm Foundation is a non-for-profit 501(c3) educational and charitable organization dependant on the financial generosity and kindness of people like YOU. Sharing the philosophy that the outside of a horse is good for the inside of any human, we ask that you make a donation to the Payne Farm Foundation. Your donation will help to provide underprivileged, neglected and abused children with the opportunity to spend the day at Payne Farm Too, building leadership, responsibility and confidence through horsemanship and farm life experiences. PLEASE DONATE TODAY!

Directions to Payne Farm Too

Payne Farm Too | 125 Dubois Road | New Paltz, NY 12561 | (845) 255-0177 | Email: Payne Farm Too


Web site designed by FELIX of Imagination Web Design. All Rights Reserved.